Saturday, 21 November 2026
The US Congressional Midterm Elections 2026 Roundup: Democracy still works, we just need to stop making bad decisions
Last month America went to the polls and elected a new Congress and, well, it was emphatic. It was historic. It surprised just about everybody. This blog most recently posted on the subject with our final forecast. Now that the dust has settled (aside from a few straggler House seats) it's time to step back and take stock of what happened.
.jpeg)
Let's start with the headline results. Democrats have won majorities in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, and also gained several key Governors' seats. But this is far from the entirety of the story.
We all knew Democrats were likely to have a good night. Midterm elections tend to favour the party out of power, and in this case the effect was magnified by the fact that 1) the incumbent Republican Party in general has fared poorly in recent midterm cycles when Trump was not on the ballot, and 2) President Trump himself is hugely unpopular, the result being that Republicans are currently struggling for support, both within the Trump wing of the party and without.
In the run up to the election, there had been some talk about poll accuracy. The common consensus is that polls have tended to overrate Democrats' chances in elections (which, as noted in this blog's preview, isn't really true), and so there had been conjecture that they may underperform on the night. The thing with polling errors is they tend not to be very predictable and don't usually follow the same pattern every year. Despite this, few seemed to consider the possibility that any such error could swing the other way, and potentially underrate the Democratic Party's position. So, if the polls were already showing Democrats in store for a very strong result, and the polls underestimated their prospects, what would that look like?
If we look at the Senate results. We all expected that Democrats would take the traditionally purple-state seats in places like Georgia and Michigan, as well as finally unseat the stubborn competitor Susan Collins in traditionally blue Maine. But it ended up being so much more than that. We also expected that they had a chance of winning in states which have tended to narrowly vote Republican in recent cycles, like North Carolina and Texas. But it ended up being so much more than that as well. We suggested that they may be able to win red leaning states such as Ohio, Iowa and Alaska. Still more. Democrats were considered to have the slimmest of outsise shots at winning in solid red Kansas. They were considered to have basically no chance at winning in deep South Carolina, the home of the Confederacy. No one had even contemplated that they could win in Mississippi. They won all three.
So the final tally is 56 Democratic seats to the Republicans' 44. That represents a gain of nine seats, the largest in almost 70 years. The median expectation ahead of election night was 51/52. This blog predicted 52 with an outside shot of going as high as 54. 56 is simply astonishing.
To be clear, this wasn't even an especially favourable Senate map for Democrats. They were defending a number of historically competitive states, and required wins in several deep red states. For them to have taken a 56 seat majority with this map is remarkable, and puts them in a real possibility of securing a filibuster-proof 60 seat majorty in the next cycle.
Meanwhile in the House, Democrats were widely expected to take the majority, with expected gains of 20-30 seats and a majority in the 230s. This blog's predictions ended up on the high end of this range, predicting a 237 seat majority. In the end, Democrats will gain around 45-50 seats, for a potentially 59 seat majority.
Now, on the surface, you might look at that and think, well sure it's a big gain, but hardly unprecedented. After all, Democrats gained 41 in 2018, Republicans gained 63 in 2010 and 54 in 1994. The difference, though, is that those large gains tended to come from a small minority. In other words, the losing party in those instances would have been holding a large number of seats in vulnerable or unfavourable districts, and thus easier for the opposition to gain. What makes this year different is that the two parties were essentially break-even going into the election, with Republicans holding a mere 5 seat majority previously. Republicans didn't lose a ton of vulnerable seats, they lost a ton of seats in what should have been safe districts. In actual fact, the Democrats' expected majority will be the largest since 1990, and their popular vote margin the largest in 50 years.
But it's also the winning margins. Democrats didn't just win Texas, they won by double digits. They didn't just win Georgia and North Carolina, they did so by 20%, the kinds of margins you would typically see in states like New York or California. It is, frankly, eye-watering.
Bottom line, this was historic. It was emphatic. Yet, even this doesn't cover the full extent of the Republicans' defeat.
All across the country, Democrats performed a near sweep of the downballot contests. They picked up pretty much all the competitive, and several non-competitive, Governors' races, with wins in Texas, Alaska, Ohio and (finally!) Georgia. They now hold enough Governors' seats to enact the long-mooted National Popular Vote Compact, which would abolish the electoral college for future Presidential elections, preventing candidates from becoming President despite receiving fewer votes.
Even aside from the mind blogging scale of the results, and the potentially significant impact it will have on both national and state-level governance, the key takeaway for me is the identity crisis which the Republican Party is facing.
Over the past decade, every vestige of what it means to be a Republican has largely evaporated, to be replaced by a movement built around a single man, Donald Trump. There are no policies, no ideals. The party is Donald Trump. This has been a primary contributor to the Republicans' poor electoral performance in midterm elections recently, and now with Trump term-limited, it asks real questions about where the party will, or can, go from here. At the moment, it's hard to see anyone who can pick up the mantle of Trumpism, and there are very real doubts about whether the party will ever be able to win back the trust of the non Trumpist voters. This is the challenge the party faces as we now head into the 2028 Presidential election cycle.
It is also worth reflecting on this cycle's results in the context of the larger trajectory of American democracy. As we wrote in our preview (as have, indeed, many other pundits and journalists) there has been a very real concern about the future of democracy in this country, with very real and tangible efforts made to subvert the principles of popular determination. Most notably January 6th, but also the fake elector scandals, the military occupations of America's cities, and so many other incidents which you can find documented here. But despite the concerns, this year's elections generally proceeded as planned, without interference or corruption. This was a completely routine and effective election, from a procedural perspective.
That has to be seen as reassuring for every American. The message this year is clear. Democracy is still alive. The electoral process still works. Ultimate power still rests with the people in this country. We just need to learn to use that power more effectively.
Make no mistake, the political implications of these results are equally significant, and will form part of any wider 2028 preview as we head into that cycle. New stars have risen, most notably in Jon Ossoff and James Talarico, the former of which is now the bookies' favourite for the next Presidential election. Suffice it to say, Texas is not a state that Republicans can afford to be losing. If that becomes the norm, the party is essentially dead in the water. The double-digit defeats in states like Georgia and North Carolina should be viewed as equally devastating. Those are not the margins you expect to see in competitive states, and unless something changes, that could prove devastating in 2028.
Governor Ron DeSantis, of all people, put it best when he called the election an extinction level event for Republicans, and really it is hard to argue. This is going to look like a very different country from next year.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



