james debate
james debate

Saturday, 15 November 2008

The Killers shouldn't work. They burst onto the scene at pace with their 2004 debut album Hot Fuss, at a time when guitar music popularity was on the decline to the point of being a joke, an industry polluted by pretty faces with no discernible talent, peddling songs that were written not by a real band, but by some bland corporate machine. They appeared clad in dandyish clothing, covered in makeup and eyeliner, a pretty frontman, they certainly looked more of the same.

5 million sold cds later they returned with their anglophilic pop stylings shed in favor of beards, black and white photos, and cheesy Americana, with songs that had more of a Springsteen taste to them. Another 4 million sold and they have returned for their third studio album with another completely different sound. Day & Age features an excess of synthpop, saxophones, caribbean steel drums, sitar strings, and 80's style funk. With such an eclectic mix of sounds and influences, this album really shouldn't work, it just shouldn't. But apparently no one has told the Killers. The Killers have come of age.

the killers day and & age review

Not only is this the best album the Killers have ever produced, it's one of the best records this year, and in this writer's humble opinion it is the most consistently good album since the Red Hot Chili Peppers' By the Way. The quality of the songs is so high throughout, that to refer to any of them as the weakest song on the album would in no way reflect any lack of quality with that particular song, but rather serve as an indication of the intense polish and care that has gone into every single facet of this album.

It is one of those rare albums where I can honestly say that there is not a single 'bad' song on the album. Some are better than others, sure, but the mark of a truly great album is how well the lesser songs stack up next to the big hits. This is an area that even in previous albums from the Killers I could point to a few tracks that didn't do anything for me, but absolutely not so this time. This is most apparent when observing a group reaction to this album; whereas with Sam's Town you generally had everyone loving When You Were Young and one or two others, and with Hot Fuss everyone was blown away by Mr. Brightside and All These Things I've Done, with this album everyone will find different songs that appeal to them on some special level. 

Whereas I love Losing Touch, I Can't Stay and This is Your Life, i've spoken to people who reckon Dustland Fairytale is one of the Killers' finest ever, or Neon Tiger, or The World We Live In. The Clash magazine's review reckons Goodnight, Travel Well is an absolute classic. The variety present in this album, as well as the high quality throughout, mean that everyone will find songs to adore here, and every song will be loved by someone, and that is not something you see with every album. Every song here is good in its own right and will grow on you if you give it a chance.

The album opens with a suitably eclectic number in Losing Touch, with classically twinkly sounding electric guitars, flanked by blaring saxophones reminiscent of 80s/90s David Bowie and harmonies and lyrics that usher in feelings of a Simon & Garfunkel epic. The first half of the song serves as a declaration of the band's return and by the time the second half comes around with its triumphant harmonies you will feel like you're in a warm embrace with old friends after a long absence. This song will grow on you big time, and is likely the third single that will be released from this album, it is also coming to Guitar Hero in a future trackpack along with Mr. Brightside and the next song on the album.

Human is the next song on the album and the first single to have been released. Probably most of you have heard this song by now. Filled with epic vocals and shiny synth, and bloody brilliant to boot, this song carries more than a few shades of the Pet Shop Boys. Produced by Stuart Price who did the 'thin white duke' remix of Mr. Brightside, this track has divided some Killers fans, with many thinking it a masterpiece and others bemoaning the electronic dance direction of the song. Personally I think it's hard not to love this track and if you've been put off by the electronics then I would encourage you to give it a chance, I think you'll find a gem of a tune underneath. And if not, the beauty of this album, as I mentioned, is that you'll find something more up your street elsewhere.

Next we come to the second single released from this album, in America anyway (still waiting for it in England), Spaceman. Taking inspiration from Bowie and Queen, this is definitely the catchiest song on the album; fast paced, driving beat, great hooks, this song is destined to overwhelm radio stations and clubs and become a singalong favorite at concerts for a long time to come. It is also the best vocal performance Brandon Flowers has ever given us, showing remarkable charisma and range, and making it all sound so completely effortless too. This song stakes his claim as a world class vocalist.

If you were ever a fan of Roxy Music or Bryan Ferry then you will absolutely adore the next track, the intensely funk and sax-laden Joy Ride. At first this was one of my less favorite songs on the album, owing to the sheer cheesiness of the vocals in some sections, but in the end this is just too catchy a song not to like, culminating in a climax that will have most rooms jumping. Another one that will grow on you.

A Dustland Fairytale is next. This song has become a favorite amongst many of the people who have heard the album so far and I can see why, but I have to say it is one of my less favorite songs. I love the Killers when they are playing uptempo songs that put you in a party mood, and this is a fairly slow ballad. But that's not to say it isn't a good song, because it is, and I still like it, just less so than other songs on the album. Starting off slowly, this song, supposedly about Flowers learning to deal with his parents getting older down the years, just grows and swells until bursting point with the pure raw emotion of the Killers' front man and a powerful build up that demonstrates the strongest narrative ever in a Killers song.

The Killers reach the apex of their eclectic mish mash of exotic sounds in This is Your Life, a song full of African chanting, electric harpsichord and spacey guitars that really just shouldn't work, and yet it all comes together in an absolutely breathtaking and epic way, forming one of the finest moments on the album as it all comes to a cathartic end with Flowers venting his soul at the audience. And again, on first listen I didn't really notice much from this track, another one that grows on you in a big way. For me, this is likely to be the most satisfying song in the long run.

I Can't Stay is one of the most unusual songs on the album, sounding completely different to anything the Killers have done before. Trading the usual stadium blasting anthems for a laid back Caribbean number with the saxophones making a return, accompanied by steel drums and one of the prettiest of the Killers' many fine melodies they've concocted for this album, a song about a young man desperately struggling for answers to one of life's big decisions, culminating in an emphatic crunch point in the final portion of the song.

Next comes Neon Tiger a song which Flowers states he wrote while trying to sound like the band MGMT, which is kinda funny since they're such a new band, but I like it since I really like Oracular Spectacular. However this is another one of my less favorite songs. It's a catchy, if slightly sluggish song about a celebrity (in my opinion Flowers himself) taking the spotlight and fighting to maintain his independence that comes together in an astonishingly intense midsection that is strongly reminiscent of Sergeant Pepper from The Beatles.

The World We Live In is the penultimate track on the album, combining a space age ambience with extreme 1980s electro pop that builds up a funky rhythm before breaking down into a chorus of airy guitars and horn. Flowers delivers another top notch vocal performance that crescendos until it's just shy of overdoing it, just enough to make this a very fine song. Even if the chorus feels a little derivative, the rest of it is very catchy.

The album closes with a 7 minute long finale Goodnight, Travel Well.. The extreme length of the song as well as the over the top darkness and heaviness was always going to make this a song that divides opinion. In the end it's not really a song that I can say I'm going to sit and listen to on the commute in the morning. The song doesn't really feel like it gets started until three minute or so into the track, when it finally begins to reveal the true intentions of the song. Those who listen patiently to the entire thing will find a slowly building powerhouse finale of epic proportions, finishing off the album with a tune so savage and raw, written apparently just after the lead guitarist's mom died, that it sounds like the sort of song U2 would use as for a big finish. It definitely works in that sense though it's hard to imagine a lot of people sitting through the full 7 minutes more than a few times to reach the thunderous, crashing finish.

I loved Hot Fuss and Sam's Town, even though I felt that with both of them some of the lesser songs were a bit weak, and with Sam's Town i didn't so much like the over the top heaviness that they went for, even though I commend them for continually trying to evolve their sound. They have done it once again with an album that sounds remarkably fresh and original. It is pleasing to see them continue to show such devotion to the music rather than becoming like so many other big bands and just peddling out the same songs over and over again for 15 years.

Clearly the album is not perfect. For starters the main reason the album is so consistently good is clearly because the album is very short, just 10 songs. However if given the choice between a short and sweet album with only the best of the best or a longer album with a lot of filler I will always take the short and sweet.

On top of this, I can't help but feel that despite the overall consistency and high quality of the album, there should really be one more mega-mega-hit. The first two singles Human and Spaceman are pretty unanimously top notch songs, but are either of them really as good as Mr. Brightside or All These Things I've Done? One of the main drawbacks of the astounding and early success the Killers achieved is the pressure to follow it up. It's hard to fault them for not quite living up to such astounding classics, most bands can only dream of ever writing songs of that quality or of the quality present with this album, but you have to feel like that one more big hit would have made the difference between a classic album and an absolutely legendary career defining album.

But really it takes a man of exceptionally poor taste or ill formed prejudice to dismiss this album based on those points. The cheesy nature will, of course, not be for everyone, but to be honest most of those people are probably not the type to go out and have a fun time listening to music like this anyway. This is the Killers doing what they do best, uplifting and addictive pop-rock. But on top of this the Killers have retained the essence of their deeper sound from Sam's Town, resulting in their most mature recording yet. This is the album where the Killers have come of age, perfecting the blend between the unique pop-rock sound of Hot Fuss with the depth and grit of Sam's Town, equally welcoming to those who enjoy the superficial exuberance of youth heard here and those who delve deeper into the core of the album.

In the end, this is an essential album for today's youth, if not a defining one. An album about excess, disposable income, champagne fountains and all-nighters with friends. These are songs for the good times in life, the nights out in Leicester Square, or the Las Vegas strip as the case may be here. This is an album exactly as one should be made, adventurous, evocative and always in search of a deeper meaning. Let this album in and it will be the accompaniment to many memorable parties, the driving force on wild nights out, and the comforting friend who keeps you company until the sun comes up the next morning. It will surely become the soundtrack to many young lives this Christmas and rightly so.



97 comments:

alex roberts said...

great review, great great review, i mean i would never even have listened to anything resembling a rock band until the killers came along

November 15, 2008  

Anonymous said...

cant wait til this comes out

November 15, 2008  

trisha said...

Amazing review! Thank you so much.

November 15, 2008  

James said...

oh and for anyone who thinks i'm just a killers fanboy writing this; for comparison i gave Hot Fuss 4/5 and Sam's Town 3.5/5 and Sawdust 2.5/5, i'm generally pretty harsh.

no, in the end this is just something special.

November 15, 2008  

mark said...

god i hate blogger, but it was worth it to read this review

November 15, 2008  

camilla b said...

i cant wait to hear this is your life it sounds amazing

November 15, 2008  

Anonymous said...

Hey everyone if you want to hear 1 minute clips of every song off new album goto http://www.the-killers.de/cover-creator/ , sounds amazing, I cant wait now. Youre welcome by the way

November 15, 2008  

James said...

cheers, good stuff.

and if you look ahead at my next post you can find full versions (on youtube) of human, spaceman, this is your life and losing touch

November 15, 2008  

Arthur Clarke said...

This review is so sugary and energetic... and the result is pretty infectious, I am now really psyched for this album.

Good review.

-Arthur Clarke
Oxford Chronicle

November 15, 2008  

dan said...

personally i liked sams town but this sounds like it might be as good too. the preivews sound tight.

November 15, 2008  

BelieveMeNatalie said...

The review was less than ok, but would every blogger please get their facts straight on the "Stringsteen" sounding Sam's Town crap. That was a comment BF made and now wishes he wouldn't have. When it comes to interviews he's stated sometimes he not socially successful with his words, so some things come out wrong. Sam's Town has nothing in common with old Brucey and bloggers need to really get the facts straight and study up on their bands before writing a epic of bs. It's The Killers, come on people, for all dedicated fans they don't need this "blog-hog review" to know the album will blow their minds once again, it's just an understanding! For anyone else, just take a TRUE fans word and listen...you'll love it for your own individual reasons. The Killers will be as great as U2 one day here shortly and to me already are! They're lyrically amazing and have an unbelievable talent!

November 15, 2008  

arthur clarke said...

To be honest, if you can listen to When You Were Young and not draw comparisons with Springsteen 'tearing down the highway' then i think you need to crank up a bit of Born to Run.

As for Flowers wishing he hadn't said that, he said it again very recently when interviewed by the Clash Magazine and made numerous comments about who his inspirations for this album were.

In any case I don't think it's a negative thing, all bands have their influences, and you're pretty clueless about music if you attempt to dismiss this. Considering it was mentioned only in passing in this review I find it odd that you belabor the point to this extent.

Arthur Clarke
Oxford Chronicle

November 15, 2008  

all these things ive done said...

I've heard a few of the songs and I can say that this review is dead on about them, this album is going to be HUGE

November 15, 2008  

observer said...

i didnt think itd get much better after the last two albums but sounds like it does, nov 24th cant come soon enough

November 15, 2008  

abe said...

im seriously jealous of people who have heard these songs... more so now

November 15, 2008  

kit said...

@natalie

if you hate these reviews so much why are you here?


personally sams town was my fave album but ic ant wait for this one

November 15, 2008  

tash said...

the album sounds pretty strong, and after reading this review im definitely even more excited for it

November 15, 2008  

mr brightside said...

it was only a kiss, how did it end up like this?

November 15, 2008  

renault said...

it was only a kiss it was only a kiss

November 15, 2008  

Anonymous said...

i cant wait to see the show for this album live. like you said this is an album about good times and fast living so the shows probably gonna be ssweet ass

November 15, 2008  

kanye said...

i have to say, one thing you can always say about the killers is that they wear their influences on their sleevb and always have so some of the comments on here are a bit... wrong.

November 15, 2008  

Anonymous said...

ooh, i got chills reading this interview lol
i cant wait for this to come out.

November 15, 2008  

chunkymonkey said...

one ting you gotta say bout the killers is they dont just play the same generic crap over and over like some bands, there one of the more adventurous groups out there.

reviewer hit the nail on the head with that one

November 15, 2008  

Andy said...

RHCP's By the Way as a benchmark? Holy Christ.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

hope the albums as good as it sound

November 16, 2008  

reggie said...

maybe this will cement their position as one of the biggest bands in the world.

have a friend who relly dislikes them so thatd be sweet.

November 16, 2008  

dan said...

good stuff, but for my money i think viva la vida still going to get album of the year

November 16, 2008  

gob said...

good indepth reveiw now i cant wait for the album to be out

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

As good as U2 one day? 5/5?....Come off it. Stop dreaming.

The 5 biggest bands still remain U2, Coldplay, Oasis, Chili Peppers, and Radiohead.....(Stones if you want to include a 6th), in no particular order.

And, before anyone even suggests it, measuring album sales is a daft way to prove which band if "bigger". Backstreet Boys sold over 100million albums, but they are meaningless now.

What makes a "big" band is cultural impact, and timelessness. Something the Killers have yet to achieve.

Oasis defined the 90s. They played to 250,000 people over 2 nights at Knebworth in 1996. And, showing they're still relevant here in 2008, they sold almost a million tickets for their tour in a matter of hours.

Furthermore, they've already stood the test of time:

Live Forever, Slide Away, Cigs and Alc, Rock N Roll Star, Supersonic, Champagne Supernova, Wonderwall, Cast No Shadow, Morning Glory, Don't Look Back in Anger, Whatever, Stand By Me, All Around the World, The Importance of Being Idle, Where Did It All Go Wrong, Gas Panic, The Turning, Falling Down, The Shock of the Lightning, Stop Crying Your Heart Out, Little by Little, Song Bird, The Masterplan....

The list is pretty much endless.

And until The Killers accumulate a long list of quality songs, until they become culturally important, and until they play sold out shows to hundreds of thousands of people, they will remain a generic pop band with only dreams of cracking the stranglehold of the top 5 current bands.

I'm sure the new album will be good, no doubt. But let's not get ahead of ourselves here.

Remember the Arctic Monkeys? Remember all that hype? Yeah, well despite being good and being the media darlings too, they failed to make a lasting impression as those aforementioned bands have already done (U2, Oasis, Chili Peppers, etc)

The Killers are a step in the right direction, but still too generic for my taste. There's nothing unique about this band.

Frankly, if you expand the list above to include great other rock bands in recent past:

The Beatles, The Smiths, The Clash, The Jam, The Stone Roses, etc...

...listing "The Killers" amongst them is just embarrassing. They're not that good.

Sincerely, le douche

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

And while we're on the subject, The Killers have released a pretty meeaningless, but yet catchy song, title "Spaceman"

But how about the Oasis song, D'yer Wanna Be A Spaceman? Which is a bloody b-side for crying out loud. It's genius.

The fact that none of The Killers songs can even compare to Oasis' b-sides speaks volumes.

D'yer Wanna Be a Spaceman:

These lyrics are just genius. Noel Gallagher is the best lyricists of our generation, whether you want to admit that or not.

I haven't seen your face round
Since I was a kid
You're bringing back those memories
Of the things that we did
You're hangin round
And climbing trees
Pretending to fly
D'Yer wanna be a spaceman
And live in the sky

You got how many bills to pay
And how many kids
And you forgot about
The things that we did
The town where we're living
Has made you a man
And all of your dreams
Are washed away in the sand

Well it's alright
It's alright
Who are you and me to say
What's wrong and what's right
Do you still feel like me
We sit down here
And we shall see
We can talk
And find common ground
And we can just forget
About feeling down
We can just forget
About life in this town.

It's funny how your dreams
Change as you're growing old
You don't wanna be no spaceman
You just want the gold
All the dream stealers
Are lying in wait
But if you wanna be a spaceman
It's still not too late

Well it's alright
And It's alright
Who are you and me to say
What's wrong and what's right
Do you still feel like me
We sit down here
And we shall see
We can talk
About common ground
And we can just forget
About feeling down
We can just forget
About life in this town.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTU8-H6PtoU

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

Debs, you have realized that there's more to music than being "commercial" and "radio" friendly, right? There's more to an album than traditional hits.

The Killers are a sell out. You think every Oasis song sounds the same?

Yeah, ok, give Talk Tonight, Live Forever, Slide Away, Half the World Away, and Don't Look Back in Anger a listen, and you'll see you're claim is bullshit.

The Killers, on the other hand, are as generic as they come. Spaceman just sounds like it's been half-heartedly cobbled together.

If you want good bands to listen to, some you may know, some you may have heard of, I highly recommend the following:

The Kinks, The Stone Roses, The Smiths, The Clash, The Jam, The Bee Jees,

And once again, the likes of U2, Oasis, Chili Peppers, etc deserve to stand along those bands. The Killers, however, do not.

The Killers are just an improved version of Fall Out Boy, and a lesser version of Arcade Fire. That's not saying much.

But hey, to each his own, right?

November 16, 2008  

James said...

You haven't heard the album and you're dismissing it as commercial? I'm not sure what world african tribal chanting and sitar strings counts as commercial but please take me there!

I'm not entirely sure how you decry a band that releases a single 10 song album as sellout and then play up the merits of coldplay who release two albums in 6 months for no particular reason? I'm not sure you understand what the phrase means.

Again, 'generic' just isn't a word that's applicable here, because only a tone deaf monkey could claim that the Killers sound like any other band, in fact that's unanimously one of their defining features, 'cheesy' perhaps, but do try to open up a thesaurus before you attempt to throw random words in here.

I'm guessing you're one of my younger readers but I think you should re-read what I wrote and you'll see that I was comparing Oasis's songs across all their albums, and yes they do just trot out the same song ideas over and over.

what i think you're forgetting is that fall out boy and arcade fire put together haven't sold as many records as a single album from the Killers, and all of Oasis' albums for the last ten years haven't either.

I'm sure you did have a point to make here, but you've not really expressed it well, throwing together a bunch of rather arbitrary words and phrases that I don't think you understand that you probably read somewhere.

November 16, 2008  

mike said...

ugh i hate it when people rant like that, i mean what kind of loser?

anyway this album is awesome ive heard like half of it cant wait til its released

November 16, 2008  

andy said...

god what an embarassing comment above. apparently the killers, who are famously protective about their music are the sellouts, while oasis who are so desperate for cash that they sell their classic hits to children's tv shows and cereal commercials are not.

:S

November 16, 2008  

sam said...

this album is going to be tiiiiight
the killers have such a unique sound

November 16, 2008  

andy said...

im sorry, but spaceman is meaningless?

the guardian described it as the killers song with the most obvious narrative... i think thats a sign that we can just stop listening to this retard- i advise you to go open a newspaper once in a while.

November 16, 2008  

cath said...

I think you are so right about the bit with eveyrone finding differnet songs to like. for examlple i am in love with joy ride its just such a great dancey tune

November 16, 2008  

bluth said...

holy christ there are some real morons in the world

November 16, 2008  

anz said...

i cant believe this stupid thing isnt out yet i mean really what are they waiting for now? the hype is built and we all really want it so come on!

November 16, 2008  

dan said...

haha come on, oasis havent released anything in like 10 years have they? i mean that's like trying to compare the everley brothers to the killers

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

what kind of dimwit actually embarrasses himself by claiming that spaceman is less meaningful than "Space and time and here and now/Are only in your mind"

some things in life really are just too depressing.

but then that's what the killers are for.

November 16, 2008  

rocko said...

this album sounds good, but i don't think it will match up to sam's town, that was a truly underappreciated rock album

November 16, 2008  

lore said...

this album is amazing. the killers were already one of the biggest rock band in the world and now theyre going to be even bigger.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

omfg these recent comments made me lol so hard, i think the guy writing about oasis is just trolling, otherwise he might as well be out here telling us how the buggles are the biggest band in the world.

November 16, 2008  

soph said...

i love the sound of this album, its one of those records that you really can relate to if youre young and you go out having a good time.

the lyrics are genius and the music is one of the most unique albums ive ever heard. its no wonder the killers have managed to revolutionize the genre to such an extent.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

rolling stones? huh? i didnt see the beatles or pink floyd or the moody blues on that list of biggest bands in the world... this guy is aware that its not 1970 anymore right?

November 16, 2008  

jill said...

very nice review, thanks for writing it, i can't wait for this album, itll probably be the best selling album of the year even with only a month of the year remaining.

November 16, 2008  

omair said...

i dont think theres any question about how unique and clever the killers are, especially after this album

November 16, 2008  

dude said...

dude, i cant wait for this album now, i mean the killers are the band that got me into rock music. until then i thought it was a genre just for depressed grungey sell outs like oasis and the smashing pumpkins.

November 16, 2008  

rachel said...

amazing review!

November 16, 2008  

herb said...

wow, i cant believe there are actually people on this planet who still hold oasis as a big band... but then i guess somewhere theres probably someone still hoping that elvis is a day away from making a big comeback.

November 16, 2008  

neon tiger said...

wow so you like the album then?

this is the kinda review that really makes me more excited about an album!

November 16, 2008  

Bluth said...

This is certainly a hype building review, but to be honest all the ones ive read so far are. it seems like this is going to be a pretty huge album.

November 16, 2008  

matt said...

best album from the killers yet thats fo sho

best album of the year probs

November 16, 2008  

kiff said...

sounds like everyone loves this album so far, looking forward to it

November 16, 2008  

graham said...

this is an amazing album, every single song sounds fresh and original. its no wonder that every review has called attention to the uniqueness in this album.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

"bee jees"? seriously? spellcheck please

November 16, 2008  

ralph said...

thank god the killers exist, the band that makes rock music cool again for the current generation.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

anyone with an even vague appreciation of music knows that the killers have always been about creating different and original music and then coming up with something completely different and new with every album. this one seems to take all that to a new extreme with one of the freshest sounds ive heard in a long time.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

Since you like to go by album sales so much, here you go:

Oasis
-Definitely Maybe: 8 million
-What's The Story: 23 million
-Be Here Now: 9.5 million
-Shoulders of Giants: 3 million
-Heathen Chemistry: 4 million
-Don't Believe the Truth: 6 million
-Dig Out Your Soul: 700,000+*

*Too early still for a substantial read of this number

Killers
-Hot Fuss: 5.5 million
-Sam's Town: 4.5 million

So before you claim that the Killers have outsold recent Oasis, check your facts, as Oasis' 2005 effort surpassed both of The Killers' albums.

Sure, The Killers have some smart lyrics, but the thing about Oasis is that he's singing about YOU.

"o understand these songs is to know what if feels like to be 18 years old, with a great haircut and a great set of clothes, walking into a club with more heart and hope than dough, and thinking - metaphorically at least - "Everyone in this shithole is going to suck my fucking dick." These are songs about triumph and adversity ('Talk Tonight'); about having nothing and wanting everything ('Rock'N'Roll Star'); about being pissed off with the world, yet coming from such a poor lot, you're too pathetically educated to be able to express such rage linguistically, and anyway, the cool-as-fuck, forever iconic, six-syllable stretched pronunciation of 'Im-ag-in-aay-shee-en' says everything you want to say much more succinctly ('Cigarettes & Alcohol'). It's also about fighting - and, if you take into account Oasis' much underappreciated, career best dewy side ('Slide Away', 'Wonderwall', 'Don't Look Back In Anger'), forgiving. Put plainly and simply, these are songs about every intake of air that goes into your lungs, swills about inside you for a bit, and then returns from where it arrived. These are songs that chronicle the experience of life."

The Killers have yet to connect to people, they have yet to find actual meaning. They create anthems, and that's it. Listening to Mr. Brightside, as catchy and as good as it is, does not ignite any emotions like a song such as Live Forever does.

November 16, 2008  

James said...

it's strange that you're surprised by the rather common sense notion that older albums sell more copies than newer albums but then going by that post I wouldn't expect much else.

for comparison, sam's town, the lesser of the Killer's two albums sold 700,000 copies in its first week compared to dig out your soul selling the same amount in two months or so.

i'm not entirely sure what it is about the oasis lyrics that you find relatable, as much as i'm sure most kids these days ponder how "Space and time and here and now/Are only in your mind" i find myself far more involved with songs about actual life-related topics and being young.

you seem to have some kind of notion that if a band sings in a lower class accent with words like "d'yer" in the title that makes them more 'rock and roll', there's quite a strong pattern to the pop bands you listed as rock bands you dig all being bands that play a similar stereotypical sound, good as some of them may be. sadly not everyone who listens to rock music these days is a penniless yobbo thug and I think Oasis should attempt to update their sound for the first time in 15 years in order to adapt to this.

you seem to keep coming back to this 'killers make anthems' shtick, you might try listening to more than just one or two songs per album, strangely enough a lot of the big oasis singles are anthems too, after all they pretty much defined the modern anthem sound some 15 years ago.

i certainly don't see how you think you relate to a rock star who sings mostly gibberish and songs about being a thug and likes to look like he slept on a park bench last night. you might think it's 'cool' but that's all just a bit stereotypical really, and a look about 15 years in the past. the killers is music with brains for people who don't just care about image.

November 16, 2008  

alex said...

man ive seen some pretty stupid trolls before but never one who was sad enough to write multiple essays on a single topic, usually they get bored and go back to whatever life they have.

November 16, 2008  

grace park said...

I hate living in america, i get this album after everyone else!

the last two albums pretty much defined the sound of todays music so i cant wait for this one to come out

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

lol

November 16, 2008  

chucko said...

actually i think you'll find he did get his facts straight. the killers have sold over 12 million albums according to the bbc since 2004, whereas oasis have sold about 10 million albums this decade, in twice as much time.

November 16, 2008  

mark said...

guys don't feed the troll, never feed the troll lol

james if he comments again you should just delete it, he's clearly spamming.

November 16, 2008  

rollo said...

i like the sound of this new album, i was a bit disappointed with the sound of sam's town so it's good to see yet another change in direction.

if the killers continue to change their sound so drastically one can only wonder what theyll prodce int he future

November 16, 2008  

This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

"james if he comments again you should just delete it, he's clearly spamming."

Yeah, ok, let's forget that we live in a democracy shall we.

Your opinion isn't law, and just because you disagree with it doesn't mean it should be disregarded.

I'm trying to stimulate an actual debate, and I find it pathetic that supposedly educated people attack someone because of a differing opinion.

I'm sorry that I actually have a formulated opinion and I don't jump on the bandwagon and follow the hype. But by all means, be sheep.

As Liam snarled "Is anyone here prepared to say, just what they mean or is it too late?"

November 16, 2008  

James said...

Sorry but I'm going to have to listen to everyone else now and delete that comment for spamming, if you really think you have a point to make please keep it manageably short. give us a few lyrics not entire lyrics sheets.

November 16, 2008  

James said...

debate is fine, but swamping a comments section with long and barely relevant lyrics sheets is spam, please keep it shorter.

November 16, 2008  

olly said...

this really is a pretty special album.

and to the oasis fan:
12 million records sold in 4 years compared to 10 million in twice as long :P

November 16, 2008  

jenny said...

excellent, my favorite review yet!

i dont see why oasis is even relevant here? seems to be a band of the past. theres no doubt the killers are one of the biggest bands in the world right now.

November 16, 2008  

James said...

for all you haters: The Times just gave this album a 5 star review, the 4th i've seen so far and there's only been a handful of reviews done. looks like i'm in good company.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

He likes Oasis, you like The Killers, whats the matter, music is just perception and opinion anyway. Move on you don't need to spend your life arguing about it on the internet.

November 16, 2008  

James said...

I like both, I just don't think Oasis have any fresh ideas left in recent years.

In any case i'm not going to discourage healthy debate, he is free to express his opinion here.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

life? you'd be shocked to hear this is all the product of one afternoon actually.

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

You totally missed the point, it's not about who you like or whether you have a life. It's about music being purely opinion based and having no way to associate fact with it. You can't argue based on opinion it will never be resolved cause their is no right or wrong. Record sales are the closest thing to fact in the music industry and even they are now skewed by illegal downloading.

And this is clearly not healthy debate when you delete someones comments, spam or not.

November 16, 2008  

hector said...

i just read the times review, sounds pretty similar to this one so sound like itl be good i hope

November 16, 2008  

James said...

Well I would be inclined to agree with you, no issue with that.

As for the delete, the only reason I did that is because it took up half the comments page with a list of several songs' lyrics sheets. I'm sorry but that was just annoying. I'm perfectly happy for him to repost his comment with a few excerpts or links.

November 16, 2008  

banterpatrol said...

too much aggro banter

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

^ best comment of the day ^
he wins

November 16, 2008  

adam k said...

if i like oasis AND the killers does that get me kicked out?

anyway i think this album sounds tops from what i've read about it, good review mate.

November 16, 2008  

stars said...

cheers for reviewing this, am jealous youve heard it!

November 16, 2008  

l&o said...

good review, i agree totally with the point about this album needing one more meeeeega hit, but it's pretty fantastic anyway

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

the killers is for gay people

November 16, 2008  

James said...

Please darling, it's FABULOUS

November 16, 2008  

Anonymous said...

lulz

November 16, 2008  

robert loggia said...

this killers album is seriously good

thats "good"
'G' as in God this album is going to be huge
'O' as in oh my god this album is going to be huge
'O' as in oh my god this album is going to be huge
'D' as in damn this album is going to be huge

November 16, 2008  

watchmen said...

sounds like this album will be the business if the reviews im reading are anything to go by

November 16, 2008  

max said...

damn i wish i could find me a copy of this album

November 17, 2008  

Anonymous said...

if your coldplay review gets listed on wikipedia, why doesnt this one? this is the much better written review if you dont mind my saying :P

November 20, 2008  

Anonymous said...

Whoa, I just re-read this quote from Anon: "The fact that none of The Killers songs can even compare to Oasis' b-sides speaks volumes."

This clown doesn't know anything, evidently.

Oasis B-Sides? You have realized that Oasis released a B-Side collection in 1998 titled The Masterplan, which went on to sell 2million copies?

Oasis b-sides are incredible, and it's one of the main reasons Oasis fans use to showcase how strong this band is.

Here are some Oasis B-sides that you probably heard of: Acquiesce, The Masterplan, Whatever

Here are some that I highly advise you to check out if you haven't heard them: Talk Tonight, Half the World Away, Rockin Chair, Listen Up, Let's All Make Believe, Flashbax, Idler's Dream, The Fame, Stay Young

^These are songs that are considered to be poor decisions to leave off albums. These are monumental songs, and any band would love to have Oasis' b-side collection as their main material.

The stupid comment from 2008 goes to you, sir. Please learn about music before you try and make absurd and outlandish comments.

Sometimes I feel like I'm dealing with 13 year olds who just hold by their convictions without having proper knowledge of anything.

January 25, 2009  

Anonymous said...

Allmusic guide gives Oasis' released B-Side collection, The Masterplan, a 4.5/5 and her's an excerpt of their review with a link to the entire thing at the end. Further highlighting how much of an idiot the author of the post in question is.

"Critics and fans alike claimed that the best of these B-sides were as strong as the best moments on the albums, and they were right....Most bands wouldn't throw songs of this caliber away on B-sides, but Noel Gallagher followed the example of his heroes the Jam and the Smiths, who released singles where the B-sides rivaled the A-sides"

http://www.allmusicguide.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:jnfexqljldse

Idiot.

January 25, 2009  

Anonymous said...

Lastly, there's nothing special about The Killers. Synthetic 80s pop is hardly original or even cool or mainstream.

They don't define a generation, most of their lyrics you can't relate to [although there's a few songs with quality lyrics, mind]. They're not even considered one of the biggest bands in the world, Coldplay sadly holds that title atm, although of course The Killers are a big band regardless.

Look, Oasis was something special in the 90s, something I'm not sure we'll ever see ever again in our life time. Yes, they've fallen from grace since, although they have become more popular since 2005. And furthermore, Oasis are still huge - you dont sell over 1 million albums, sell 1 million tickets in 1 day, get a #1 in the UK and a #5 in the US (which is the highest Oasis have received here since the 90s! So clearly they're even more relevant than ever) if you're not big.

Oasis have a number of songs that will be remembered in 50 years time, sure most of them are from the previous decade, although not all of them, but I doubt while Live Forever and Wonderwall are still being played on the radio in 2050 that we will be able to say the same thing about Mr. Brightside.

What makes a band big is it's legacy and timeliness. Oasis have proved to have had that, regardless of what you think of the band post-2000. The Killers have yet to achieve that, and if they ever will is yet to be seen.

January 25, 2009  

Anonymous said...

I forgot to make this last point:

Oasis are the last proper rock band. A story of strife and hardship where they came from a poor, working class family, abusive and alcoholic dad who they left and moved one random day when the brothers were growing up. The story of how Oasis formed is special, and now unique in today's modern times.

Oasis is, in essence, the last real proper band. They were the band of the people, represented the average citizen, and their songs reflected that, too. While they are millionaires, they still hold to those ideals, although their songs don't reflect it anymore, really. And rightfully so, because Noel has stated many times that he can't sing about being poor and on the dole anymore because that would be fake.

Oasis, paradoxically, are a band with morals. They're the most honest band around. Just listen to their quotes, even!

I don't think we will ever see a band this successful of meaningful ever again. Good luck to the Killers complaining about The World That We Live In in 80s synthetic style; it will never hold a candle to the meaningful tunes such as Cigarettes and Alcohol, Live Forever, Slide Away, etc

Oasis revolutionized rock. Oasis inspired a generation. Oasis provided hope. Oasis told the truth about society whether it was in interviews or the lyrics of the songs. Oasis represented how you any average person could become something special. Oasis have created songs for our generation. Oasis were a cultural movement in the 90s. Oasis will go down as one of the best bands ever, standing side by side with the likes of The Kinks, The Jam, The Smiths, hell, even the Beatles and Led Zep.

None of this, absolutley none of this, can be applied to the killers. So regardless of the killers selling a few more albums that oasis currently is meaningless.

The Backstreet Boys sold over 100million albums, does anyone care about them anymore? No. There's more to it than album sales, and Oasis were the full package.

January 25, 2009  

James said...

ben you must lay off the booze, for all our sanity's sake.

January 25, 2009  

Newer Post Older Post Home