Monday, 10 November 2008
Apparently one Coldplay album this year is not enough for us. Viva La Vida was a very good album too by the way, a vast improvement on the mediocrity that was X&Y. But even so I don't think anyone really expected they would release any more music this year, even a small half-album such as this, but credit to them.
I think it is a better idea to release music in small chunks rather than one big album every three years, it's too long to wait and then when it comes it's harder to appreciate all those new songs at once, I hope it's something that catches on, though I'm sure I'll be eating my words in a minute if this EP turns out to be crap, so without further ado here is my review of Prospekt's March.
Well I won't have to eat my words because it's pretty good. In fact I think a number of these songs are better than some of the weaker numbers on Viva La Vida, and I can't help but feel they should have put some of these on there.
Starting of with Rainy Day, this is a very nice song, vintage Coldplay, but it suffers from being, frankly, too similar to the song Viva La Vida and perhaps isn't the fresh sound we'd hope for from the first song on the album.
The title track Prospekt's March/Poppy fields is something pretty special. A somber and melodic tune full of emotion that yields to the second of Poppy fields, and does so, in my opinion, much more effectively than any of the two part songs in the proper album. This is certainly one of the key songs from this release.
Glass of Water is... decent, it builds up to a pretty satisfying conclusion, though much of it feels a bit throw-away compared to some of the other songs. It is still better than a number of the lesser viva la vida songs.
Life In Technicolor II is a song that had given me very high hopes, being billed as life in technicolor, one of the best songs in the viva la vida album, except fully fleshed out to a full length song with vocals. Sadly only half of that is true. This song basically turns out to be the same bit of music on repeat with vocals laid on top. Mind you that's not a terrible thing, it's a great piece of music, probably the best that Coldplay have written in terms of pure musical excellence.
Lost+ is a re-release of the song Lost, which I never much cared for, except with the rap stylings of Jay-z on top... which actually makes it a bit better, this works much better as a rap song than as a pop song and adds another kind of dimension to the music, good call on this one.
Lovers in Japan was one of the better songs from Viva La Vida, and so this Osaka Sun Mix is very welcome here. It is definitey the definitive mix, and skips out the rather redundant 'reign of love' segment attached to the end of it on the album release.
Postcards from Far Away is a song I can see a lot of fans not liking, but it's something I wish I would see the band do more often. Stop relying on electronics and pop synthesizers and return to the old coldplay style with real guitars and pianos, as they have done here A very pretty piece of music for sure, but not something that's going to be setting the charts alight any time soon.
The finale Now My Feet Won't Touch the Ground is a rather interesting new song from Coldplay, one of the most sparing in terms of instrumental depth which leaves the album ending on somewhat of a flat note, even if it is by no means a bad song it still seems a bit of an anti-climax.
So in closing, this is a welcome addition to my music library, brief though it is, but while these are pretty decent songs, I can't help but feel most of these are good enough to have replaced the filler on the viva la vida album, but perhaps not much better. There's nothing here that you'll remember ten years from now, but if these songs had replaced some of the dross from the big album then that really would have been one hell of an album, but alas.
Stay tuned for my next big album review, The Killers- Day and Age, i've not heard all the songs yet but it sounds like a scorcher.






alex roberts said...
huh? another one?November 10, 2008
camilla b said...
<3 ColdplayNovember 10, 2008
Erin said...
Err... any thoughts on the closer song "Now My Feet Won't Touch the Ground"? Or is this all based on those little preview clips we've all been hearing?November 10, 2008
James said...
well i don't know about previews, the full versions of all the songs can be heard in one place or another if you know where to look.except for that last one for which i've heard like 5 seconds, and can't really comment on.
p.s. i dont 'have' any of the songs, that would be illegal of course :P
November 10, 2008
lorey said...
who cares coldplay suck balls anywayNovember 10, 2008
Abe said...
ha I love it, you're getting attacked by fanboys in both your album reviews. The oasis fsnboys wrote an essay though so they win.Time for the killers fanboys to sound off next week?
November 10, 2008
James said...
yikes i didn't expect this, it's respirocytes all over again!just to clarify my comments because I clearly should have spent more time on this review: Prospekt's March feels a lot like a b-sdes album much like Sawdust from the Killers and Another Weekend in the City from Bloc Party.
it was announced only a few months after viva la vida- only a few songs, seemingly all remixes or songs that were either not finished in time for viva la vida or deemed not good enough for it.
my point was that some of these songs are actually pretty good and better than some of the weaker songs on viva la vida, so if some of the better songs from this EP had been on viva la vida, then viva la vida would have been, for my money, a more consistently good album than it was, rather than this somewhat unusual 1 and a half albums in 6 months they have released instead.
all the best
-James
November 10, 2008
Anonymous said...
I´d really appreciate if you´d turn on your msn account :)November 10, 2008
James said...
it's on? that would have been a lot more helpful without the anonymity.November 10, 2008
lara said...
Oh i´m sry, misclicked :(is your msn james@colorstripe.com ?
i´ve added you: lara
November 10, 2008
camilla b said...
ah but what you're missing is that the album works as a whole, you wouldn't get that if you replaced any of themNovember 10, 2008
James said...
well see thats an interesting point... some of the less-good songs i probably didn't like enough to notice those things, and so to the coldplay community i apologize.to be honest i'm not getting paid nearly enough for this... in fact i'm not getting paid anything at all. and damn right it shows.
November 10, 2008
Anonymous said...
to be honest it is a complete b-sides collection, so i'll give you that one.November 10, 2008
Anonymous said...
nme gave it a mediocre review tooNovember 17, 2008
Anonymous said...
I don't think you've actually heard Prospekt's March...because honestly, your descriptions are pretty off, bud.November 20, 2008
robert said...
from what i've heard of the ep so far i would have to agree with most of this review.i mean why release one good album and one 'ok' album in the space of 6 months? they could just have made one awesome album
November 20, 2008
andy said...
man i wish i could hear this ep, though i must say im not exactly expecting a classic going by the early reviewsNovember 20, 2008
tom said...
most reviews ive read so far seem to miss out that last song, i dont think it was included on the preview copies that were sent around maybepity cos i want to hear it
November 20, 2008
Anonymous said...
Hi everyone...What does really mean Prospekt's March?? any help on this?? Thanks....
March 13, 2009